As L'Oreal Voluminous Carbon Black is one of my favorite mascaras ever, I thought I would try its sister L'Oreal Voluminous Naturale to see if I could tell any difference.  Well, I can!  And that's not a good thing.  While the Carbon Black version of Voluminous offers thick, long, sooty black lashes, Naturale doesn't do this at all!  I did notice a bit of length and maybe even a touch of thickness, but it was hard to see past all the extreme clumpage!!!  Argh!!  Shock and horror, y'all!  This is not at all what I look for in a mascara.  I want long, lush, inky black lashes, not spider legs!

I will try again, just to see if maybe I got a bad tube, but I am majorly disappointed.  The brush is rubbery, like Cover Girl Lash Blast, but skinny and flexible and ugh!  Not a fan.  Not a fan.