Jo Dee Messina’s outfit was too casual for an awards ceremony. Messina is a legend, but she gets lost in the crowd wearing little more than a leather jacket and jeans.

The fit of Miranda Lambert’s silky blue gown was tragic. There’s nothing wrong with a plunging neckline, but the dress looked downright uncomfortable in the décolletage department.

Nicolle Galyon’s outfit was an undeniable flop. The dress hung limply like any run-of-mill nightgown without any color or accessories to distract us from this fact.

The hot pink and deep purple paired nicely on Caroline Munsick’s floor-length gown, but the mixed-up animal prints did not. Her denim pumps also did her no favors.

Carly Pearce’s look was simply uninspired. She wore a demure, peach-colored gown that was virtually indistinguishable from the slinky prom night garb of the early 2000s.