Hallmark Star Nikki DeLoach's Best Beauty Looks In Her 40s (So Far)

When Nikki DeLoach steps out, she proves again and again that women in their 40s can pull off fun, glowy, and glamorous beauty looks. The Hallmark star turned 40 in September 2019, and Nikki DeLoach has continued to stun on the red carpet with her cool fashion sense. But it's her makeup and hair that have really caught our attention over the years. She's experimented with colorful eyeshadow, creamy blush, and several different hair colors that bring out the best in her features.

In a December 2025 interview with New Beauty, DeLoach said, "In terms of how I approach beauty, I give myself a lot of grace. This can be a struggle, but I'm trying to fully adopt that mindset ... you see your lines and your wrinkles, and it's so hard not to be like, 'Oh God, make them go away.'" She added, "So I'm trying to flip that to: 'No, there's a lot of life that I've lived.'"

Although DeLoach is a fresh-faced beauty with no makeup on, we love seeing how she highlights her natural features and tries new beauty looks. She is beautiful — inside and out — and we are taking notes for our own makeup routines.

Nikki DeLoach stepped out in one of her most glamorous looks yet in New York City in November 2025, proving that women in their 40s can switch up their style at any time. She rocked a dramatic smokey eye, complete with white eyeshadow at the inner creases, and false eyelashes that really made her eyes pop. She paired it with a light pink lip gloss and a dewy foundation that looked stunning. And did we mention how much we love that sleek lob?

A change in season is the perfect time to switch up your makeup routine, which Nikki DeLoach is an expert at. DeLoach nailed a darker, fall beauty look at a Hallmark event in October 2024. Her wavy hair was dyed a dark brown, which complemented her coral blush and mauve lip gloss. She used a more neutral eyeshadow color with perfectly applied mascara, which looked great but didn't distract from the rest of her face.

Makeup inspiration can come from anywhere, and Nikki DeLoach turned to her own outfit for hers. When she attended an event celebrating People's 50^th anniversary in September 2024, DeLoach matched her eyeshadow to her dress. She looked gorgeous in a red-and-blue flower print dress, which was complemented by the blue eyeshadow that covered her lids and her lower lash line. The rest of her makeup was more subtle with light pink lips to keep the focus on her eyes.

Nikki DeLoach looks pretty in pink! She opted for a glowy, pink makeup style to match her bold, one-shoulder hot pink dress at the Children's Hospital Los Angeles Gala in October 2022. For this look, she used dewy highlighters in gold and pink on her face, paired with pink lip gloss and bold pink eyeshadow. DeLoach looked like a goddess — or like Barbie herself! — with makeup that brought out her pretty, soft features.

Nikki DeLoach switched up her foundation at the "Cruel Summer" Season 2 premiere in May 2023, which made a bigger difference than you might expect. She used a full-coverage matte foundation and just a little bit of blush that made her skin look flawless. For her eyes, she stuck with neutral browns that looked beautiful with her highlighted brown hair. DeLoach's go-to light pink lip gloss completed her look with just the right pop of color.

Nikki DeLoach embraced the sparkly holiday season by adding glitter to her eyeshadow at the Hallmark Channel's "Countdown to Christmas" event in October 2025. She wore a gorgeous silver dress with glittery butterflies, which looked festive with her light pink glittery eyeshadow. She wore a slightly darker, cherry pink lip gloss and skipped the eyeliner under her eyes for this look, which was even more elegant with her dark blond hair in an updo.

Certain eyeliner colors are the most flattering on women in their 40s, including deep plum. Nikki DeLoach wore this exact color at the Children's Hospital Los Angeles Gala in October 2024, and it looked fabulous with her hazel eyes. She paired the purple liner on bottom with black liner on top and tons of mascara to make her eyes look stunning. Everything from her rosy pink cheeks to her reddish-brown hair was perfect.