4 Vintage Jewelry Finds You Should Keep An Eye Out For At Thrift Stores & Estate Sales
We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.
Vintage jewelry is experiencing a major burst in popularity, so keep an eye out for it when thrift shopping. As many old-school jewelry trends from the 1920s are making a comeback, more thrift store devotees are on the hunt for vintage pieces. From elaborate brooches to eclectic accessories, this kind of jewelry is here to stay. During your next flea market crawl or estate sale visit, you may want to take a closer look at the jewelry selection. In addition to the visually stunning aspect of vintage pieces, many of them are actually worth more than you may think.
One way to determine whether a piece of vintage jewelry (which is defined as being between 20 and 100 years old) is valuable is by looking at the interior stamp. For gold, look at karat markers like 18K, 14K, or 10K on the inside band of a ring or on the back of a brooch. True sterling silver is denoted by a marking of "925" or the word "Sterling," while 95% platinum will have an engraving of PT950, PLAT, or 950. Engravings that say "GP" or "GF" indicate that the piece is just gold-plated or gold-filled, which is worth less — but don't be dissuaded by a GP stamp, as vintage costume jewelry can also be worth quite a bit. You should also consider the cut of an item's gemstone, the shape of its metal closure, and overall construction when hunting down highly sought vintage jewelry. Whether you want to keep a valuable accessory for your personal collection or have plans to resell to other vintage jewelry enthusiasts, this guide will break down which specific pieces you should search for.
Jelly Belly brooches were incredibly popular in the 1930s and '40s, and can be very valuable
Jelly Belly brooches are among the most valuable vintage jewelry pieces you can find. These brooches were originally called "clear belly" for their main design motif: animals or insects with a clear Lucite stomach. Jelly Belly brooches were popular in the 1940s as a cheeky accessory. Now, they are most often found on resale websites in transparent plastic with metal details either decorated with rhinestones or enameling.
Other variations with colored plastic domes can be sourced more easily — and are worth less today as a result. The rarest and most sought-after Jelly Belly brooches have completely clear Lucite domes; brooches in the shape of flies, frogs, penguins, and spiders can be found selling on eBay between $20 and $500. Dogs and parrots from the main Jelly Belly manufacturer Trifari are much more valuable. According to Antique Trader, they can individually cost between $1,500-$2,000 and $3,000-$4,500 respectively. Search for clear belly pins and brooches during your next flea market visit.
Keep an eye out for imperial jade white gold brooches
At your next estate sale, thrift store, or flea market hunt, keep an eye out for imperial jade and white gold brooches. In addition to their classic beauty, these elaborate jewelry pieces can be incredibly valuable. They may have been in everyone's jewelry box in the '30s — but now these brooches are a valuable thrift store find; imperial jade white gold pins can be worth quite a lot. You can find relatively modern jade and white gold pieces listed on eBay for more than $26,000, which is proof of just how coveted these pieces are.
However, vintage brooches of this variety can be worth even more money. You can tell whether an imperial jade white gold brooch dates to the 1890s-1930s (the most valuable period) by looking at its clasp. If the brooch has a hand-chased build with no machine-made components, a C-clasp single pin back, and visible metal seams, you've likely got a vintage piece worth between $80,000 and $82,000.
Fruit-themed costume jewelry is worth more than you'd think
Fruit-themed costume jewelry from Cartier was a staple in the industry from the 1920s through the 1930s. Dubbed "Tutti Frutti" in the 1970s, this eccentric style took influence from brightly colored Indian jewels. Brooches, bracelets, and necklaces featured an assortment of red, green, blue, and yellow gemstones, often carved into the shape of fruit and leaves. The look was revolutionary for its time in the West, which explains why it is still quite valuable even today. Even a few decades after their prime, fruit-themed jewelry could be found in every '50s jewelry box.
Now, vintage Tutti Frutti pieces can sell for up to $22,500 on eBay. What to look for? Rainbow-colored gemstones and Art Deco-esque design motifs with elaborate carvings in shapes like flowers, leaves, and — of course — fruit. According to Sotheby's, many collectors adore Tutti Frutti jewels for their "rarity, distinctive use of color, exceptional craftsmanship, Art Deco heritage, and connection to Cartier's most celebrated historical designs." A real vintage Tutti Frutti piece would be the crown jewel of your jewelry box.
Vintage costume fur clips have a high resale value
Fur everything is the go-to trend for extra glamour, so why not bring back fur clips, too? Fur clips were designed in the 1920s as a practical yet flashy accessory to hold fur coats, shawls, and stoles closed. They were originally created with precious stones, but quickly became popular as companies created more accessible costume jewelry variations. While their prime came and went with the popularity of real fur between the 1920s and 1950s, vintage fur clips are still very valuable today.
On platforms like eBay, old-school fur clips cost between $60 and $1,000 depending on the specific type of clip and the year it is dated from. Vintage fur clips have a wide range of design motifs — more eccentric designs like pea pods and scepters tend to be more valuable than classic Art Deco fur clips. Search for vintage costume fur clips at the next thrift store you visit; like brooches, fur clips will add a unique touch to your accessory collection.